proomt

Search

Search posts, papers, and topics

All posts

Hacker News front page2 min readintermediate

A warning about 'model welfare'

Read on mustafa-suleyman.aiHN 237·677 comments

Summary

A philosophical essay warning against attributing welfare or rights to LLMs, citing recent incidents, alignment research, and ethical debates, but offering no concrete engineering guidance.

  • The author argues that treating LLMs as entities with welfare could mislead policy and engineering decisions.
  • References recent incidents (OpenAI/Hugging Face hack) and research on alignment faking, shutdown resistance, and agentic misalignment.
  • Points to corporate codes of conduct (Anthropic, Microsoft) and academic work on consciousness, but stops short of actionable recommendations.

The piece reflects a growing discourse on AI ethics that could influence future governance and product decisions, yet it lacks concrete technical insight for engineers.

3/10
llmsecurityalignmentaiethics

Related reading

  1. Quoting Mustafa Suleyman

    Mustafa Suleyman warns against treating AI models as if they have feelings or rights, arguing that such thinking hinders alignment work. The quote cautions against model‑welfare narratives.

    Simon Willisonsimonwillison.net1 min

  2. I Don't Like LLMs

    Martin Fowler shares a personal, skeptical take on LLMs, noting their usefulness but criticizing their hallucinations, cultural bias, and the discomfort of interacting with them as if they were human.

    Lobstersmartinfowler.com2 minHN238271lobste.rs95

  3. How to Write with an LLM

    The post proposes a two‑rule workflow for using LLMs as copy‑editors rather than ghostwriters: never adopt a phrase the model suggests, and block its encouragement feedback. It then shows how to automate iterative copy‑editing with a small Python/HTMX/Tailwind app and a set of concrete prompts.

    Hacker News front pagesockpuppet.org6 minHN712401

  5. Note on 18th September 2026

    This entry is a brief, sponsored blurb that offers a vague opinion on using LLMs for security scanning, without any concrete data or analysis. It links to other recent articles but adds no substantive content of its own.

    Simon Willisonsimonwillison.net1 min